Too Many Choices?

CCTV installers face seemingly endless transmission options

Remember the 1984 movie "Moscow on the Hudson," where a Russian immigrant, played by Robin Williams, is befuddled by an entire supermarket aisle filled with an endless array of coffee product choices?

CCTV choices are a bit like that—with literally thousands of cameras, DVRs and IP solutions to choose from. Most installers select their products based on recommendations from sales representatives or from those stocked by their favorite distributor. Other times, the choice is made simply based on what has worked in the past. Although the results of these choices are usually predictable, this comfortable approach does not foster improvement in performance, cost or serviceability. In this competitive economy, it's those choices that allow the innovative installer to come out ahead.

Perhaps the single most expensive part of the installation is transmission. Transmission encompasses the transport of video signals, camera power and, sometimes, telemetry data between the camera and the storage and monitoring location. It is often overlooked when designing a CCTV system.

Selecting a transmission solution depends on the application. Installers need to consider whether the camera installation will be fixed or PTZ. Will heaters, blowers or IR illuminators be required? Will the cameras and peripheral equipment receive local power, like 12 volts DC or 24 volts AC? Other questions include, how long are the cables between the cameras and control equipment? Does the installation require an underground or other wet cable-pull? Is conduit access available? And finally, how important is the perception and/or need for IP cameras?

Once these questions are answered, end users may select an optimal transmission method. Compare your needs against the available solutions:

  • Which method provides the most appropriate picture quality?
  • Which method has the lowest materials cost?
  • Which method has the lowest installation (labor) cost?
  • Which method is most easily expandable and standards compatible?
  • What later additions, changes or IP migration are contemplated?
  • Which solutions are most easily serviced?
  • What level of reliability and support is needed?
  • What is the total cost of ownership, and who bears that cost?
It's easy to dismiss one solution as being more expensive based solely on equipment cost. However, when thorough analysis includes the labor of pulling power and/or telemetry cables, serviceability or the calculation of the total cost of ownership, specifiers are often surprised by changes in the expense gap between solutions.

Coax. Most CCTV installations still use coax cable. This wire is acceptable for short distances but quickly becomes expensive at longer distances due to its large copper composition. It also is an unbalanced transmission line, which means it can be susceptible to interference. Coax cables must be kept away from power cables and other interfering sources. They do not have immunity to ground differences, which can result in ground-loops or hum-bars.

PTZ telemetry can be supported up to about 1,000 feet using up-the-coax protocols. However, camera power and longer distance telemetry require additional cable pulls, or expensive and bulky Siamese cable.

The CCTV industry is one of the last to abandon coax cable in favor of structured building wiring.

Conventional wireless. Expensive radio devices are used when the transmission path is inaccessible. This method works best in line-of-sight applications. Bandwidth is limited, and the video is often susceptible to interference.

Fiber. The non-conductive nature of fiber works well in long-distance, lightning- prone or high-noise environments.

Cost, radius of curvature, installer tools and skills, and the inability to send power make this an outlier technology.

Ethernet. This solution, used by IP cameras, is easy to install, supports structured building wiring practices (EIA/TIA 568B standards) and can support distances up to 300 feet. PoE allows the camera to be powered through the same four-pair Cat-5 cable.

Materials costs are significantly higher when one includes IP cameras and enterprise- level routers. Higher priced labor and reliability is the Achilles' heel of this technology. Configuration, warranty service and ongoing maintenance costs often present a rude TCO surprise.

Wi-Fi. Also used by IP cameras, this solution has interference, bandwidth and potentially serious security issues, in addition to those of Ethernet.

Hybrid video. Growing in popularity, this reliable solution allows camera power, analog video and RS-422/RS-485 telemetry to reside within one low-cost fourpair Cat-5 cable. It supports structured building wiring practices (EIA/TIA 568B standards) and can support distances up to 2,000 feet, depending on camera power.

RJ-45 connections can be easily tested and verified with a handheld LAN tester. Cameras may be powered from power supplies located mid-span in IDF closets, or from the MDF room (head-end), facilitating UPS backup.

As a balanced transmission line, it is inherently interference immune and has built-in transient protection. Video signals can be sent several thousands of feet when active (amplified) devices are used. Further, the customer can migrate to an IP solution if desired. Often, when deploying a hybrid solution, IP is just a video server away.

Selection of a good transmission method may not be as daunting as a camera or DVR selection, but its impact on system performance, reliability, future IP migrations and cost can often make the difference between a winner and a money pit. Choose wisely and consider costs/performance, flexibility and overall ROI/TCO.

Featured

  • Allegion, Comfort Technologies Implement Mobile Credentials at the Artisan Apartment Homes in Florida

    Artisan Apartment Homes, a luxury apartment complex in Dunedin, Florida, recently transitioned from mechanical keys to electronic locks and centralized system software with support from Allegion US, a leading provider of security solutions, technology and services, and Florida-based Comfort Technologies, which specializes in deploying multifamily access control, IoT devices and software management solutions. Read Now

  • Mall of America Deploys AI-Powered Analytics to Enhance Parking Intelligence

    Mall of America®, the largest shopping and entertainment complex in North America, announced an expansion of its ongoing partnership with Axis Communications to deploy cutting-edge car-counting video analytics across more than a dozen locations. With this expansion, Mall of America (MOA) has boosted operational efficiency, improved safety and security, and enabled more informed decision-making around employee scheduling and streamlining transportation for large events. Read Now

  • Security Industry Association Launches New “askSIA” AI Tool

    The Security Industry Association (SIA) has unveiled a brand-new SIA member benefit – askSIA, a conversational AI agent designed to help users get the most out of their SIA membership, easily access SIA resources and find the latest information on SIA’s training and courses, reports and publications, events, certification offerings and more. SIA members can easily find askSIA by visiting the SIA homepage or looking for the askSIA icon in the top left of webpages. Read Now

    • Industry Events
  • Industry Embraces Mobile Access, Biometrics and AI

    A combination of evolving workplace dynamics, technology innovation and new user expectations is changing how people enter and interact with physical spaces. Access control is at the heart of these changes. Combined with biometrics and AI, mobile access control has become increasingly crucial for deploying entry solutions that are seamless, secure and adaptive to user needs. Read Now

  • Sustainable Video Solution Delivered for Landmark City of London Office Development

    An advanced, end-to-end video solution from IDIS, with a focus on reducing waste and costs, has helped a major office development in the City of London align its security with sustainability objectives. Read Now

New Products

  • A8V MIND

    A8V MIND

    Hexagon’s Geosystems presents a portable version of its Accur8vision detection system. A rugged all-in-one solution, the A8V MIND (Mobile Intrusion Detection) is designed to provide flexible protection of critical outdoor infrastructure and objects. Hexagon’s Accur8vision is a volumetric detection system that employs LiDAR technology to safeguard entire areas. Whenever it detects movement in a specified zone, it automatically differentiates a threat from a nonthreat, and immediately notifies security staff if necessary. Person detection is carried out within a radius of 80 meters from this device. Connected remotely via a portable computer device, it enables remote surveillance and does not depend on security staff patrolling the area.

  • Connect ONE’s powerful cloud-hosted management platform provides the means to tailor lockdowns and emergency mass notifications throughout a facility – while simultaneously alerting occupants to hazards or next steps, like evacuation.

    Connect ONE®

    Connect ONE’s powerful cloud-hosted management platform provides the means to tailor lockdowns and emergency mass notifications throughout a facility – while simultaneously alerting occupants to hazards or next steps, like evacuation.

  • Automatic Systems V07

    Automatic Systems V07

    Automatic Systems, an industry-leading manufacturer of pedestrian and vehicle secure entrance control access systems, is pleased to announce the release of its groundbreaking V07 software. The V07 software update is designed specifically to address cybersecurity concerns and will ensure the integrity and confidentiality of Automatic Systems applications. With the new V07 software, updates will be delivered by means of an encrypted file.