Courts Biometrics Ruling Poses Risk to Technology Companies

Court's Biometrics Ruling Poses Risk to Technology Companies

The Supreme Court of Illinois ruled Six Flags Great America collected a boy's thumbprint without proper consent.

The Supreme Court of Illinois on Friday ruled that an amusement park must pay damages to a boy for collecting his thumbprint without proper consent. The decision in the closely-watched case opens the door for the possibility of huge payouts in related cases against technology companies whose face-scanning policies breached a state law known as the Biometric Information Privacy Act.

In the Six Flags Great America case, a mother named Stacey Rosenbach filed a lawsuit upon learning the amusement park scanned and stored her son's thumbprint as part of its annual pass program. The case soon became a key test of the law, known as BIPA. The crucial issue is whether a person must show they suffered actual harm when a company collects biometrics without permission, or if its enough to just show that the act took place.

In a 7-0 ruling, the Illinois court agreed with Rosenbach that the purpose of the law, which provides for a $1,000 to $5,000 penalty, is to deter companies misusing consumers' biometrics. This meant Rosenbach's son counts as an "aggrieved person" in the language of BIPA.

This ruling comes as a blow to companies like Facebook and Google who are also currently tangled in BIPA lawsuits of their own. In the case of Facebook, consumers are claiming the social network scanned their faces without permission as part of a feature to "tag" friends, and in the case of Google, part of a facial recognition service for Google Photos.

Today, a number of other BIPA lawsuits are hanging in the balance against companies like SnapChat and Shutterfly. The cases seem to divide themselves into those claiming illegal face-scanning and those claiming their fingerprints or thumbprints were taken without permission.

About the Author

Sydny Shepard is the Executive Editor of Campus Security & Life Safety.

  • Ahead of Current Events Ahead of Current Events

    In this episode, Ralph C. Jensen chats with Dana Barnes, president of global government at Dataminr. We talk about the evolution of Dataminr and how data software benefits business and personnel alike. Dataminr delivers the earliest warnings on high impact events and critical information far in advance of other sources, enabling faster response, more effective risk mitigation for both public and private sector organizations. Barnes recites Dataminr history and how their platform works. With so much emphasis on cybersecurity, Barnes goes into detail about his cybersecurity background and the measures Dataminr takes to ensure safe and secure implementation.

Digital Edition

  • Security Today Magazine - November December 2022

    November / December 2022

    Featuring:

    • Key Tech Trend
    • Is Your Access Control System Cyber Secure?
    • Constantly Evolving
    • The Talent Shortage
    • Looking Forward to 2023

    View This Issue

  • Environmental Protection
  • Occupational Health & Safety
  • Spaces4Learning
  • Campus Security & Life Safety