The Picture of Health

New Yorkers recently had their trust violated when they found out that a Long Island pediatrician was indicted for sedating young girls in his office and sexually assaulting them as part of what he told them was a “medical procedure.” The main evidence against the pediatrician? Video of the crimes, recorded by a surveillance camera hidden among items on the doctor’s desk.

Doctors typically use cameras to prevent criminal behavior rather than to record it. Prescription drugs are enticing, and even regular medical supplies, especially needles, can be a target for a petty thief – or an unscrupulous employee. There’s always good, old-fashioned money to steal, too, from the cash register or from unaware patients biding their time in the waiting room.

Surveillance cameras can prevent and help prosecute these losses, but installing them in medical offices raises a host of privacy issues, much as the camera in the Long Island pediatrician’s office would have had patients known it was there. An expert in burglar and alarm law, Ken Kirschenbaum, of Kirschenbaum & Kirschenbaum PC, said cameras in doctor’s offices often inhabit a legal gray area.

“Many jurisdictions have specific statutory prohibitions for particular areas – bathrooms, dressing areas, bedrooms – where it’s illegal to install and utilize cameras,” he sad.

He added that there are two types of law surveillance systems could violate. The first a statute such as those he mentioned, where state specifically bars cameras in doctors’ offices. The second comes from common law. This commonsense legal tradition holds that it is unlawful to have surveillance in areas where a person can have a reasonable expectation of personal privacy, because the surveillance would violate that expectation of privacy.

Kirschenbaum said that, depending on the state, the liability for privacy violations can extend beyond the end users to include integrators who install a system in an area such as a patient examining room in which it will clearly violate a person’s privacy. This is something integrators should watch out for.

But doctors need not consign themselves to the continual loss of supplies and cash to theft; Kirschenbaum said that, in his opinion, doctors can install cameras in such a way as to avoid legal trouble.

First, he said, patients should be well aware that they are being filmed. Installing surveillance cameras in conspicuous areas and posting signs about their presence should indicate to patients that they are being watched. Going a step further, doctors should ask patients to sign consent forms, which would provide additional assurance that the patients know and understand that surveillance cameras are recording.

Additionally, the location of the cameras matters, too. “The camera can be installed in a waiting room, focused on a counter, for example, where doctors leave supplies and things of that nature,” he said. “Perhaps they have hypodermic needles – the camera should be focused strictly on that, not any area where a patient would be treated.”

Above all, Kirschenbaum said, to diminish the probably of legal problems resulting from surveillance, be careful with the footage once it’s been captured.

“The greatest risk (of legal action) in any CCTV situation or audio listening device situation is really the misuse of the data once it’s collected,” Kirschenbaum said, “because even data that is viewed and collected illegally, if no none knows about it, there’s not going to be any (legal) issues.”

About the Author

Laura Williams is content development editor for Security Products magazine.

Featured

  • Report: 15 Percent of All Emails Sent in 2023 Were Malicious

    VIPRE Security Group recently released its report titled “Email Security in 2024: An Expert Look at Email-Based Threats”. The 2024 predictions for email security in this report are based on an analysis of over 7 billion emails processed by VIPRE worldwide during 2023. This equates to almost one email for everyone on the planet. Of those, roughly 1 billion (or 15%) were malicious. Read Now

  • ASIS Announces ANSI-Approved Cannabis Security Standard

    ASIS International, a leading authority in security standards and guidelines, proudly announces the release of a pioneering American National Standards Institute (ANSI)-approved standard dedicated to cannabis security. This best-in-class standard, meticulously developed by industry experts, sets a new benchmark by providing comprehensive requirements and guidance for the design, implementation, monitoring, evaluation, and maintenance of a cannabis security program. Read Now

  • ISC West Announces Keynote Lineup

    ISC West, in collaboration with premier sponsor the Security Industry Association (SIA), announced this year’s dynamic trio of speakers that will headline the Keynote Series at ISC West 2024. Read Now

    • Industry Events
  • Government is Top Targeted Industry for DDoS Attacks in Q4 2023

    The government sector experienced a surge of DDoS attacks in Q4 according to Lumen Technologies (NYSE: LUMN), a global leader in integrated network and cybersecurity solutions. The Lumen Quarterly DDoS & Application Threat Report for Q4 2023 analyzes data from its DDoS mitigation platform and application protection partner, ThreatX, to provide an overview of the DDoS and application-layer attacks that targeted organizations in the last quarter of 2023. Read Now

Featured Cybersecurity

Whitepapers

New Products

  • EasyGate SPT and SPD

    EasyGate SPT SPD

    Security solutions do not have to be ordinary, let alone unattractive. Having renewed their best-selling speed gates, Cominfo has once again demonstrated their Art of Security philosophy in practice — and confirmed their position as an industry-leading manufacturers of premium speed gates and turnstiles. 3

  • Hanwha QNO-7012R

    Hanwha QNO-7012R

    The Q Series cameras are equipped with an Open Platform chipset for easy and seamless integration with third-party systems and solutions, and analog video output (CVBS) support for easy camera positioning during installation. A suite of on-board intelligent video analytics covers tampering, directional/virtual line detection, defocus detection, enter/exit, and motion detection. 3

  • Camden CV-7600 High Security Card Readers

    Camden CV-7600 High Security Card Readers

    Camden Door Controls has relaunched its CV-7600 card readers in response to growing market demand for a more secure alternative to standard proximity credentials that can be easily cloned. CV-7600 readers support MIFARE DESFire EV1 & EV2 encryption technology credentials, making them virtually clone-proof and highly secure. 3